Simultaneous control of knob/xy pad

[mwhlr]

Hi there,

Attached is a control scheme I've been working on. I'm having some issues with it and was wondering if anyone had any suggestions?
It's part of a VST in which 2 methods are provided to control some parameter - an xy pad and a knob.
This means that, in order to work realistically, the two control methods also need to control one another.

dualcontrol.osm

(277.81 KiB) Downloaded 757 times

So far, the knob can be controlled using the pad and it's working very well. However, I'm struggling with the knob controlling the pad. I am able to move the xy pad cursor using the knob, but when I stop dragging, the knob snaps back to its initial position. I've been at this for a few hours now, but still no luck. Does anyone have any suggestions? I'll explain what I've done so far:

The method I've used might not be the most efficient way. The pad outputs a value of 0 - 1. This output enters the knob control module and into a select primitive. The select is controlled by the "interact" boolean on the DragY primitive. If the knob is not being dragged, the output from the module is the pads value, else it is the knobs value, hence the pad can control the knob.

Inside the pad, there are other selects. One is controlled by the boolean variable of the DrgXY primitive. It determines what value is sent to the F2A primitive. If the pad is being used, the pad's own X value is sent to the F2A. If it is not being used, the knobs output value (scaled to match the pads grid size) is sent to the F2A. This should allow the knob to control the pad.

Finally, the boolean variable "interact" from the knob is sent into the pad. This is used to determine what the output value of the pad is. If the knob is being used, the knobs output also becomes the pad output (you can see this more clearly in the schematic). I'm not even sure if this is required - it may even be causing part of the issue? My thought process what that if moving the knob did not actively change the pad output value (which in turn is going back into the knob), the knob would snap back to the value whenever it wasn't being used.

Apologies for the long-winded post. I'd appreciate any suggestions, as I'm pretty stuck with this.

[Tronic]

dualcontrol_pad_knob_(Tronic).fsm

(127.51 KiB) Downloaded 807 times

[mwhlr]

That's fantastic Tronic - Much better than what I was attempting to do.
It certainly seems using Flowstone's animated knob instead of Synthmaker's might have helped.